“Who’s a Looter?”
This article by Tania Ralli shows two different pictures both taken of hurricane Katrina survivors. One picture shows a young black man carrying food and pop with a caption underneath that suggests he was looting a grocery store. The second picture shows a white couple also carrying food and drink but the caption under this photo says they found bread and water. When I started reading this article, I immediately agreed with the bloggers who thought that the difference between the two captions was a purposefully made racial statement. To me, the young black man and the white couple were doing the exact same thing; they were both in the middle of a crisis and were doing what they could to get the resources they needed to survive. It is kind of ironic that the caption under the black man had more of a negative vibe to it than the caption under the picture of the white couple. As I continued to read, I realized that the two photos came from completely different agencies. I then agreed that the negative statement under the picture of the black man probably wasn’t meant to come across the way it did when compared to the same type of photo from another agency. The two agencies claim to have different standards on how they write their captions, which makes the incident seem even more unintentional.
Many times things that are not truly racial issues tend to be portrayed as racial issues by critics and/or society. Don’t get me wrong, sometimes certain situations are racial issues and need to be dealt with, but I’m not sure that is the case here with this article. This article controversy reminds me of that shooting that happened in Lima a year or so ago. There was a somewhat of a huge uproar about whether it was a racial issue or not. I never saw it as a racial issue and I know many people, black and white, who felt the same way. At times, a situation is what you make it out to be. Would there be the same level of questioning with these photos if the caption under the white couple claimed that they were looting, and the caption under the black man had more of a positive connotation? I think sometimes people make a big deal out of something that is not intended to be such a big deal. I think it would be awesome if people could just see people as people; not white or black or Mexican or any other ethnicity. If people could look at one another through a colorless lens, I think the world would be a very different place.
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I have not read this article but when I read your blog it definetely sounded racial. Like you said though, does it really matter? Okay so one company sends out a caption that seemed sort of rascist, but I mean really. There are tons of other issues in the world that could use the effort people put into trying to pull the rascist card on other people. For instance with the shooting here in Lima. If people would have just dealt with the fact that it happened and couldn't be fixed and helped the family out I'm sure the whole situation would have turned out much better.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis is so true! It seems like so often, people try to make everything into a racial scandal. Yet if that could be overlooked, more attention could be focused on actually working to fix the situation. We are all humans, does a small thing like skin color really change that? I don't believe so. We were ALL made in God's image. The same image of the same God. If people could just see that we are all the same, I believe that this world WOULD be a better place.
ReplyDeleteI really like how you make the point in the end that people make a big deal out of situations that probably were not intended to be a problem. Also I think how you connected this story to the shooting in Lima was a really good example of how to put it into perspective. Racial tension is such a touchy topic, but you did a good job of being down to earth put things back into perspective. :)
ReplyDeleteThis piece makes some interesting points, but look at the organization. Look at the paragraph structure. You've ranted and rambled, not thoughtfully discussed--you could have structured this so the points and analysis were much more logically set forth. You've got ideas, but you didn't take the time to structure them to your best advantage.
ReplyDelete